New York Mets ‘never had a real chance’ at top SP in MLB free agency, seemingly used as leverage

The New York Mets went into MLB free agency hoping to make a big splash with one of the best, young talents available. After a spending spree on veteran starting pitchers backfired in previous offseasons, New York was determined to take a smarter approach this winter.

The Mets had their sights set on Japanese starting pitcher Yoshinobu Yamamoto for a reason. Not only was he the top pitcher in MLB free agency, but he also had a reputation for thriving in the spotlight. He seemed like the perfect fit for New York.

There was intense competition for Yamamoto’s signature, with the Dodgers, Yankees, Phillies, and Giants all vying for his services. Ultimately, he chose the Dodgers, but it was believed that the Mets, Yankees, and Dodgers were the main contenders. Even if the Mets had offered more money, it might not have made a difference.

According to Jon Heyman of the New York Post, there is a suspicion that the Mets never really had a chance at signing Yamamoto. It had been reported months earlier that he preferred to play on the West Coast, and he seemed to confirm that in his introductory press conference with the Dodgers.

Even if the Mets had offered Yamamoto the $50 million signing bonus he desired, it might not have swayed him. Yamamoto and his agent used the Mets’ offer as leverage in negotiations with the Dodgers, just like the biggest stars do with other MLB teams. New York wouldn’t have had a shot at him unless they significantly overpaid.

With Yamamoto as their top target this offseason, the Mets are now shifting their focus to second-tier free agents who won’t require expensive long-term contracts. While this may be the best move for the team in the long run, being used as leverage by top free agents will present some challenges for the club in 2024.